Liquid Eyeliner

My one, and only, eye liner. I’ve been using this eyeliner for years (guessing 5+ years) - it is perfect. It meets all of my eyeliner needs: •clean, safe ingredients - a must for my beauty products and especially for something next to your eye! •stays put all day. Like legit. (does not smear) •easy to apply (liquid and application tip are spot on for an easy application) •easy to fix an application error (wet a q-tip and run it along the line for an easy, effective clean up). •no odor. IYKYK. I’m allergic to fragrance & it is surprising how many makeup products have fragrance added to them! Not this one! I’ve used a ton of Honest brand products for over a decade now. Some are great, some are so/so. This eyeliner is perfection. I hope they never stop making it.

Pretty good. I wanted something gentle for sensitive eyes, and easy to apply and remove. This fits the bill. Doesn't bother my eyes at all. Matte after drying. It does seem to get in your eyes a lot during removal, but I'm not sure if that's normal for liquid eyeliner. VERY messy during removal/touch ups. I don't have oily skin or sweat much, but if you do, this one may not be for you. It comes away very easily with water or makeup remover and smears all over, so be aware of that. I haven't had any trouble with it coming off or smudging throughout the day, except in the lower outer corner as sometimes I have tearing there, not noticable, though.

I've been wearing this for about 3 months now and I've been pretty happy with it's performance! PROS: - Great for everyday wear (minimally irritating/harmful ingredients especially compared to most on the market) - Great pigment - Stays on all day - Quick and easy to remove (my preferred method is an oil, like hemp seed oil, or oil-based cleanser) CONS: - The tapered shape of the applicator is not super ergonomic and I've found that it's a bit more difficult to feel like you have control over your application compared to pencil/marker shaped applicators (resulting in some accidental lines from time to time). HOWEVER, you do kind of get a feel for it after awhile and you just need to be extra steady - Not waterproof in the least bit. I KNOW THAT THIS IS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE WATERPROOF. But I was a bit caught off guard at just how susceptible to smearing/running it is when exposed to water. I was cutting onions and my eyes started tearing up a bit, and after I was done, I looked in the mirror and the eyeliner that was previously only on the top of my lid was covering my undereye area. --- it was just an unexpected level of the eyeliner bleeding. (so if you have watery-eyes maybe caused my allergies, then this is NOT a good liner for you)

This is my favorite eyeliner. For me, it is absolutely much proof, but not waterproof. It’s very concentrated I noticed, which gives it a very tense black look. Which I love. But it also means that as soon as water comes in contact with the eyeliner, it creates a mess. But that’s often the case, tears, etc. always make Makeup run. I love this eyeliner.

This product is ok. I bought it because I was looking for eyeliners with "clean" formulas that rated well on the Yuka app. The eyeliner looks good when first applied but doesn't last throughout the day. It is very easy to smudge, and if the smallest amount of water touches it, you look like a member of KISS with a huge smear across your face. The applicator tip can make it hard to apply the eyeliner where you want it (but that could also be some user error on my part). Over all the product is just ok. I did repurchase it because I haven't found a better alternative yet, but know you are buying mostly an applicator with a tiny amount of product.

This is very messy eyeliner. I had to remove my eye makeup twice because I thought my mascara was running so I removed it first. I still had black on my lids and under my eye so I knew it was the liner. It burns as well. Do not recommend you purchase this

Great clean eyeliner! It goes on nicely and thin. But not water proof in the slightest, a watery eye will melt it away

Never buying any other mascara again!!! 😍 It’s so good! It doesn’t clump, and the primer makes it apply so nicely and builds so much volume without looking thick! I’ve NEVER felt comfortable just wearing mascara out, but I went out with just this today and felt so cute! It’s super comfortable and I don’t even notice that I have it on. I’ve had it on all day at the time I’m taking these pictures and leaving this review and I can confidently say I love it and highly recommend it!!! It makes my lashes look so long and dark and the applicator is PERFECT for close application without getting it all over my eyelids (which is usually my problem lol)